About Supplement Verdicts
We review direct-to-consumer supplements by reading what the seller actually publishes, then comparing it with published research. That's it. No testing claims, no invented customers.
Why this site exists
Most supplement reviews online repeat the sales page. We checked 701 competitor review snippets ranking in the top three on Bing. Across all of them, 0% stated a price, 1% gave a rating, and 2% mentioned the guarantee terms.
Those are the three things a buyer wants first. So that's where we start.
What we do on every review
- Read the seller's full sales page and order section, and record every price and shipping charge exactly as shown, with the date we checked.
- Look for a Supplement Facts panel. If there isn't one, we say so plainly, because that absence is itself the answer to a lot of questions.
- Compare the named ingredients against published human trials, and cite those trials by their PubMed identifier so you can read them yourself.
- Price the product against named alternatives that do publish their amounts.
What we don't do
We don't take the products. This is desk research, and every review says so. Anyone claiming a personal result from a supplement after a few weeks cannot separate it from ordinary day-to-day variation, so a first-person anecdote would tell you nothing useful.
We don't publish invented customer reviews, stock-photo testimonials or countdown timers. If you've read a few supplement sites you'll know exactly what we mean.
Who writes it
The Supplement Verdicts editorial team. We don't put an invented person's name and face on these reviews, which is common on supplement sites and tells you nothing — a byline you can't check is worth less than a figure you can.
What you can check is the work. Every review names the seller's page each number came from, gives the date it was read, cites research by PubMed identifier, and carries a dated note of what changed when it's updated. If a figure no longer matches the seller's site, tell us on the contact page and we'll correct it and say what changed.
We are a small independent publication. We are not a retailer, and no supplement company owns any part of this site or can pay for a score.